Do you think being a critic is wrong?

In a statement on the website appeared to suggest that being critical of some of the songs the LP is tantamount to being a bad fan, because the role of fans is supporting the team.


For me it is an expression of naivete, because if you see that your friend is sinking into dependence you try  help him somehow and turn him out of the way which will lead him to death. So just follow a good friend!


My criticism of the ATS due to the fact that I am convinced that it is the way of degradation of the LP, as I already explained  in other threads.


Recent statements suggest that the next album will be back for more rock sound and I hope there's some real merit us the true fans of LP  who tried to show the evil inherent in the ATS.

Views: 65

▶ Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Permalink Reply by Stefan Sestovic on July 12, 2011 at 1:48pm
Being critic isn't wrong definitly... But some fans are making themselvs important saying some words that will defend LP from critics, and then, they are all big fans...Big fans? hahaha :D 

http://www.linkinpark.com/forum/topics/linkin-parks-new-album-3 topic about new album... ;)

Permalink Reply by Daniele Rodrigues on July 16, 2011 at 8:57pm

I agree with Kathy. 

If different things are done, like music, unconventionality for a band like LP, there will always be a part that will not like. But there has limitations to criticize.

KATHYxx said:

Being a critic is not bad.

Being an unconstructive critic is bad.

Also, phrasing a subjective opinion like it was objective fact is bad. So is making up objective sounding facts to justify your opinion (I don't like ATS. therefore ATS is evil. BZZT. Logic fail.).

 

The thing is, music is a very subjective thing. Saying ATS is the "degradation of the LP" or "evil" like you somehow determined that objectively is that kind of stupid crap that gets people upset with you. Realize that your opinion is only opinion, and nothing more.

▶ Reply to Discussion

RSS

Members

Forum

Linkin Park's best album?

Started by Jordan Taylor in LINKIN PARK. Last reply by nayeem islam 15 minutes ago. 531 Replies

What your fav album by Linkin Park?A underground one?Hibrid theroy?Meteora?Minutes To Midnight?A thousand Suns?Or one of there side projects? ( eg; fort minor or LP and Jay-Z )Continue

Tags: Album, favs, Best, LinkinPark, Linkin

Help me design an app

Started by Victor van den Brink in THE BARRACKS. Last reply by nayeem islam 15 minutes ago. 47 Replies

Hello dear Linkin Park fans!Some of you might me familiar with Music for Relief, the charity that was set up by Linkin Park in the wake of the 2004 tsunami that devistated Thailand.Well I am doing a…Continue

Tags: interview, application, Relief, for, Music

What Linkin Park Song Describes your life?

Started by CanaanSydnor in LINKIN PARK. Last reply by nayeem islam 16 minutes ago. 565 Replies

The Linkin Park song that would describe my life would be From The Inside

Linkin Park in Ukraine

Started by Oksana Osifliak in LINKIN PARK LIVE. Last reply by nayeem islam 16 minutes ago. 38 Replies

Hey people :) I am a simple girl from Ukraine who was waiting for LP show for about 11 years!!! Can you imagine? But LP have never been to Ukraine. I think it is unfair! We have 45 millions of…Continue

Tags: Ukraine, in, LP

Groups

Videos

  • Add Videos
  • View All

Latest Activity

jane dotrice posted a status
"http://www.thisis50.com/photo/enjoy-preakness-stakes-2013-live-stream-online-horse-racing"
9 minutes ago
0 Comments
jane dotrice posted a status
"http://www.thisis50.com/photo/nbc-preakness-stakes-2013-live-stream-online-horse-racing-online"
10 minutes ago
0 Comments
jane dotrice posted a status
"http://www.thisis50.com/photo/live-streaming-preakness-stakes-2013-watch-horse-racing-nbc"
10 minutes ago
0 Comments
jane dotrice posted a status
"http://www.thisis50.com/photo/nbc-preakness-stakes-2013-live-streaming-online-horse-race"
10 minutes ago
0 Comments
Clark Anderson posted a status
"http://storify.com/fedelcastro/uisdjshfues"
12 minutes ago
0 Comments
Clark Anderson posted a status
"http://storify.com/fedelcastro/uisdjshfues"
12 minutes ago
0 Comments
Profile IconRyan Hilley, David Radlak, Herman Nag Belpas and 6 more joined LinkinPark.com
12 minutes ago
Vihan Geria posted a status
"http://www.eteamz.com/trplcwnro/"
15 minutes ago
0 Comments
nayeem islam replied to Jordan Taylor's discussion 'Linkin Park's best album?'
"http://my.opera.com/watchliveonlinerugby24live/blog/ http://my.opera.com/watchliveonlinerugby24live/blog/ http://my.opera.com/watchliveonlinerugby24live/blog/ http://my.opera.com/watchliveonlinerugby24live/blog/ http://my.opera.com/watchliveonlinerug…"
15 minutes ago
nayeem islam replied to Victor van den Brink's discussion 'Help me design an app'
"http://my.opera.com/watchliveonlinerugby24live/blog/ http://my.opera.com/watchliveonlinerugby24live/blog/ http://my.opera.com/watchliveonlinerugby24live/blog/ http://my.opera.com/watchliveonlinerugby24live/blog/ http://my.opera.com/watchliveonlinerug…"
15 minutes ago
nayeem islam replied to CanaanSydnor's discussion 'What Linkin Park Song Describes your life?'
"http://my.opera.com/watchliveonlinerugby24live/blog/ http://my.opera.com/watchliveonlinerugby24live/blog/ http://my.opera.com/watchliveonlinerugby24live/blog/ http://my.opera.com/watchliveonlinerugby24live/blog/ http://my.opera.com/watchliveonlinerug…"
16 minutes ago
nayeem islam replied to Oksana Osifliak's discussion 'Linkin Park in Ukraine'
"http://my.opera.com/watchliveonlinerugby24live/blog/ http://my.opera.com/watchliveonlinerugby24live/blog/ http://my.opera.com/watchliveonlinerugby24live/blog/ http://my.opera.com/watchliveonlinerugby24live/blog/ http://my.opera.com/watchliveonlinerug…"
16 minutes ago
nayeem islam replied to Jordan Taylor's discussion 'Linkin Park's best album?'
"http://my.opera.com/watchliveonlinerugby24live/blog/ http://my.opera.com/watchliveonlinerugby24live/blog/ http://my.opera.com/watchliveonlinerugby24live/blog/ http://my.opera.com/watchliveonlinerugby24live/blog/ http://my.opera.com/watchliveonlinerug…"
16 minutes ago
nayeem islam replied to Victor van den Brink's discussion 'Help me design an app'
"http://my.opera.com/watchliveonlinerugby24live/blog/ http://my.opera.com/watchliveonlinerugby24live/blog/ http://my.opera.com/watchliveonlinerugby24live/blog/ http://my.opera.com/watchliveonlinerugby24live/blog/ http://my.opera.com/watchliveonlinerug…"
16 minutes ago
nayeem islam replied to CanaanSydnor's discussion 'What Linkin Park Song Describes your life?'
"http://my.opera.com/watchliveonlinerugby24live/blog/ http://my.opera.com/watchliveonlinerugby24live/blog/ http://my.opera.com/watchliveonlinerugby24live/blog/ http://my.opera.com/watchliveonlinerugby24live/blog/ http://my.opera.com/watchliveonlinerug…"
16 minutes ago
nayeem islam replied to Oksana Osifliak's discussion 'Linkin Park in Ukraine'
"http://my.opera.com/watchliveonlinerugby24live/blog/ http://my.opera.com/watchliveonlinerugby24live/blog/ http://my.opera.com/watchliveonlinerugby24live/blog/ http://my.opera.com/watchliveonlinerugby24live/blog/ http://my.opera.com/watchliveonlinerug…"
16 minutes ago

Photos

Loading…

© 2013   Created by Linkin Park.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service