Hard to say. Minutes to Midnight is getting kicked out of the favorite list (not thats its god awful, its just not that good). Its a bet between A Thousand Suns and Meteora, but I'd have to say A Thousand Suns. Its more creative, and the songs have a meaning, which when you find it out, makes the songs better.
But most people don't care for meanings. I do . . . sometimes.
for me : 1) A Thousand suns
2) Minutes to Midnight
3) Meteora and Hybrid theory :D i can't choose ! :D
Im doing a project on them and we need 10 song playlist so either list top ten songs in your opinion or best album. Also pick your favorite song by them, I have to have a listening example.
I love so many songs from every album, I don't really have a favourite - I am loving listening to A Thousand Suns because it is the newest so it's more exciting to me right now, but I love them all very much. Meteora was my first favourite cos it was the first one I owned so I got to really appreciate its music first (though I heard Hybrid Theory first but couldn't afford the album, then Meteora came out when I could just afford one new one, so I got it instead of Hybrid as I hadn't heard it yet), but I've loved every one of them and played them many many times since coming to own them. :-)